• 2 Posts
  • 240 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 6th, 2023

help-circle


  • Nope, those mean different things!

    If I didn’t like it, I wouldn’t post it

    Means (or implies)…

    “I didn’t like it, so I won’t post it”, but it’s phrased as a conditional statement.

    It also means that it’s hypothetical – nothing was posted!

    But…

    If I didn’t like it, I wouldn’t have posted it

    Means (or implies)…

    “I like it, so I posted it”, again phrased as a conditional statement.

    It also means that the thing actually happened (because the commenter liked it).

    So they have similar, but different meanings. The key difference is whether the commenter is saying they have already posted something or not. One is hypothetical, and the other is more of a reflection of something that did happen.

    Also, I think this part of your comment is incorrect.

    Should not it be

    This should be…

    Shouldn’t it be

    (This is what people say probably 99% of the time)

    Or

    Should it not be

    (This is less common and more formal)

    And yes, I know that it looks like the “not” should be directly after the “should” because of “shouldn’t”, but it doesn’t happen that way. I think this happens when forming a question with conditional verbs (should/would/could), but I have no idea why.

    As I’m sure you know, English is crazy. Sorry about that. Hope this helps!















  • I’ll wear one on public transit in the winter. It reduces the chance I’ll get sick (or as sick), and it keeps my face warm when I get back outside.

    The last time I got really sick was the last time I was in the office and at least two people nearby were sick. None of us were wearing a mask. It took me out for a solid two weeks, and I had residual effects for almost a month longer (at the minimum).

    Because of that, I could understand someone wearing a mask in the office all the time – they wouldn’t want to not wear a mask, then put it on the second they hear someone cough, lol



  • Regarding your question about being the past tense, they are also used that way. But you also need to make other changes.

    Would you like coffee?

    This is not about the past. As others have said, this is an offer of coffee. The response is

    Yes I would. / No I wouldn’t.

    (Or any other acceptance of an offer)

    Would you have liked coffee?

    This is about the past. It means something like…“Before, is it possible that you wanted coffee?”

    It’s a little tough to explain. But a person might ask that question if invited a friend to a café, got there before the friend, and ordered two teas…then the friend looked disappointed about having a tea. “Sorry, do you not like tea? Would you have liked coffee instead?”

    The answer here is

    Yes I would’ve. / No I wouldn’t have.

    It’s a similar situation for “could”.

    Could you take out the trash?

    This is a request. As others have said, “would” could also be used as a request here, but it’s not very common (at least like this).

    Literally, I think it’s a question of capability. I think “could” means “is it possible for X to happen”…but we use it to be a request because of politeness. English speakers don’t think about it this way when making a request, but it will help understand what it means in the past.

    Could you have taken out the trash?

    This is a question about a past capability. It means something like…“Before, was it possible that you were able to take out the trash?”

    You’d ask this if your kid didn’t take out the trash and you want to know if it was possible (with the implication being that you want to know WHY).

    The kid would answer

    Yes, I could’ve, but …

    Or

    No, I couldn’t have, because …

    Or

    Not now mom/dad, I’m playing a game

    As you can see, using would/could in the past is possible, but complicated. “Should” is also usable in the past.

    Should I wear a hat?

    … Is a question about whether you need a hat (maybe before going outside for a walk).

    Should I have worn a hat?

    …is a question about whether you needed to wear a hat before. Maybe you didn’t wear a hat and got a sunburn on your scalp. Ouch! Yes, you should’ve worn a hat.